Cart 0

Upcoming holiday specials!

Easter 4/1 (Sunday)

In advance of 4/1 we will switch from our March Menu to a temporary Easter Menu by 3/25

All pies will be decorated for your easter activities.

Place an order by 3/28 to have Handpie Boxes or Full Pies in Easter Flavors picked up or delivered by 3/31.

Easter menu

Coconut Honey Custard

  • TruBee Local Honey (Arrington, TN)
  • Jack Daniels TN Honey Whiskey (Lynchburg, TN)
  • Certified Naturally Grown Eggs, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Flavorganics Coconut Extract
  • Handmade Swiss Meringue
  • Sweetened Flaked Coconut & Chocolate Candy Eggs
  • Graham Cracker Crust (Can be requested GF)

Lavender Lemon Chess

  • Organic Lemons
  • Certified Naturally Grown Eggs, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Dried Lavender, Stomping Grounds Herbal (Inglewood, Nashville, TN)
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust
  • House-made Corsair Distillery (Nashville, TN) Vanilla Bean Vodka & Lavender Spiked Whipped Cream/Icing

Strawberry Rhubarb 

  • Organic Strawberries & Rhubarb
  • Sugar in the Raw
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust (Can be requested Vegan)

Green Eggs and Ham

  • Certified Naturally Grown Eggs, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Farm Fresh Spinach, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Local, Pasture-Raised Pork Cured Ham, Pilaroc Farms (Fayetteville, TN)
  • Browned Butter & Basil Sauce
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust

pies are baked up fresh every tuesday and friday.

all pies are available as handpies in market [can reserve in advance]

Full pies or handpie boxes can be special ordered for pick up in east nashville or local delivery (includes $5 delivery charge).



About CaityPies

CaityPies is a pie bakery in Nashville, TN that bakes handpies and traditional round pies to order.  We are a small business, baking in our kitchen on Tuesdays and Fridays, so please order pies at least 5-7 days in advance or find us at local markets while supplies last!

CaityPies began as a home bakery in East Nashville and has expanded to serve our local community.  We believe that the growth of small business depends on mutual support, so all of our flavors feature local produce & products.


Our Pies

CaityPies are always handmade from the crust to the filling, hand wrapped, and hand delivered.  Our flavors utilize local spirits & beer, and we always bake in season with local produce in Tennessee.

CaityPies specializes in our half-moon, individual sized Handpies.  We also produce traditional round pies in Full and Mini sizes for events and by special order.  



"You could fill that crust with mud and it would still be a good pie.  It's all in the crust." - Lynn


"Cait...your pie was such a hit at the family thanksgiving that dad hid the pie and wasn't sharing it with anyone else!  No one was allowed to take a slice home!" - Erin


"We love caitypies!!" - The thompson kids


"Just had my first bite of pie.  better Put me down for another order. Delicious." - Howard