We. Bake. Pies.
We bake handpies with cocktail influenced flavors.
We bake full pies with nerdy, funny customized crusts.
The week of Thanksgiving we will only be baking full 9” sweet pies in order to keep up with demand.
We have a list of 5 available flavors.
Pies are available for pick up on Tuesday 11/20 and Wednesday 11/21. No deliveries available.
Ordering will close when we hit capacity OR the weekend of 11/16.
Started at the bottom…
We bake pies with a purpose. Read our unconventional business journey here and our philosophy to stay honest, weird, and accepting of all bodies via food.
What People Are Saying
"It was out of this world Cait!"
"We had your tomato pies for dinner tonight, annnnnnd that recipe is absolutely a 10/10! Might even be in my top 3 favorite flavors of your so far, though that's a tough call."
"I am seriously obsessed"
-Anniemarie on her third visit in a week.
"CAITY! HOLY SHIT! IT'S SO GOOD!"
"We're doing our best to spread the CaityPies gospel."
"Just reporting from my entire day of eating CaityPies. That's right [...] Breakfast, lunch, and dinner just now and holy moly. They are ALL incredible [...] you're doing great things."
-Gabi aka Stinky
"I'm not even a pie person. But I loved that pie. I ate 7 in a week... Not just the best vegan pie I ever had. Just the BEST pie I ever had."
"If I were a mid-century hobo, I would definitely steal that off your windowsill"
"Best handpie in the WORLD!"
- Also everyone
"We loved it"