Cart 0
 
IMG_1546.JPG
 
ACS_0033.JPG

April menu

Place an order by Tuesday each week to receive a delivery or pick up at one of our markets/ pop-up events.

Coconut Honey Custard

  • TruBee Local Honey (Arrington, TN)
  • Jack Daniels TN Honey Whiskey (Lynchburg, TN)
  • Certified Naturally Grown Eggs, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Flavorganics Coconut Extract
  • Graham Cracker Crust (Can be requested GF)

Lavender Lemon Chess

  • Organic Lemons
  • Certified Naturally Grown Eggs, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Dried Lavender, Stomping Grounds Herbal (Inglewood, Nashville, TN)
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust
  • House-made Corsair Distillery (Nashville, TN) Vanilla Bean Vodka & Lavender Spiked Whipped Cream/Icing

Green Eggs and Ham

  • Certified Naturally Grown Eggs, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Farm Fresh Spinach, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • Pasture-Raised Cured Ham, Boar's Head
  • Browned Butter & Basil Sauce
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust

Spicy Moroccan Carrot

  • Roasted Organic Carrots
  • Roasted Chickpeas
  • Galena Garlic's Ras El Hanout Spice Blend
  • Cucumber Yogurt Dipping Sauce

 
IMG_E1495.JPG
 
ACS_0080 (2).JPG

all pies are available as handpies in market [can reserve in advance]

Full pies or handpie boxes can be special ordered for pick up in east nashville or local delivery (includes $5 delivery charge).


Upcoming Holiday Specials/Preorders

National Blueberry Pie Day - Saturday, April 28th 

Celebrate Blueberry Pie Day in Style!  Full Blueberry Pies will be available Saturday 4/28 ONLY for pick up at the Nashville Farmer's Market 8am-12pm. 

Two Flavors: Classic Blueberry Pie and Blueberry Rock And Rye Pie.  Place your order for Full Pie or Half Dozen Handpie Box - $30 Each.


Strawberry Fest Pre-Orders - Wednesday, May 2nd- Saturday, May 5th

We will be selling out of Strawberry pie all week, so make sure to pre-order your full pie of our Strawberry Fest Flavor: Strawberry Rhubarb Rum!

We will be debuting our Green Door Gourmet Strawberry filled pies at Green Door Gourmet on Wednesday 5/2, Hip Donelson Market on Friday 5/4, and the Nashville Farmer's Market on 5/5. 

You can pick up your pie at any location - just indicate where in the notes!

Place your order for Full Pies or Half Dozen Handpie Boxes - $30 Each


Kentucky Derby - Saturday, May 5th

Celebrate the Kentucky Derby with boozy pie!  Pies will be available Saturday 5/5 ONLY for pick up at the Nashville Farmer's Market 8am-12pm.

Two Flavors:

"Not Kentucky Derby" Mojito Pie: Black Bottomed (Chocolate) Bourbon Pecan Pie with Mint Cream

Brown Derby Pie: Grapefruit Custard with Bourbon Honey Cream

Place your order for FULL PIES ONLY $30 (no handpies of these flavors)


Cinco De Mayo - Saturday, May 5th

Get your Cinco de Mayo On!  Pies will be available Saturday 5/5 ONLY for pick up at the Nashville Farmer's Market 8am-12pm.

Key Lime Margarita Pie Full Pies!

(Plus check out our May Menu for more Cinco de Mayo Inspired handpie flavors - Taco Pie, Churro Pie - Come and get it!)

Place your order for Full Pies and Half Dozen Handpie Boxes - $30 Each


ACS_0027.JPG

Our business

CaityPies are completely handmade, hand wrapped, and hand delivered.  

CaityPies utilize local ingredients and alcohol, and we rotate our flavors every month to bake in season with local produce in Tennessee.

Read our Pies page to learn more about our philosophy for our business, our history, and pies we have created.

ACS_0057.JPG

your pie

Do you want a pie that will celebrate someone, a special treat, or a pie that sends a message?  Contact us to discuss a design, a flavor, and the timeline to get pie for your next event, as a gift, or just as a treat for yourself!

Use the delivery page to see our current options, delivery area, or start your order.

Look through the FAQ page to see if your question has been asked before and to learn more about our process.

"You could fill that crust with mud and it would still be a good pie.  It's all in the crust." - Lynn

 

"Cait...your pie was such a hit at the family thanksgiving that dad hid the pie and wasn't sharing it with anyone else!  No one was allowed to take a slice home!" - Erin

 

"We love caitypies!!" - The thompson kids

 

"Just had my first bite of pie.  better Put me down for another order. Delicious." - Howard

 

"If I were a midcentury hobo I would definitely steal that pie off of your window sill" - Alan

 

"[This is] What heaven must taste like!" - The Walsh Kids

IMG_6802.JPG