Cart 0
Sweet & Savory

May menu

Our menu changes at the beginning of every month!

Place an order by Sunday night each week to receive a delivery or pick up at one of our markets/ pop-up events.

Strawberry Rhubarb Rum

  • Green Door Gourmet Strawberries (Nashville, TN)
  • Fresh Rhubarb
  • Organic Lemon Zest
  • Stolen Distillery Smoked Rum
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust

Key Lime Margarita

  • Nelly & Joe's Original Key Lime Juice
  • Certified Naturally Grown Egg Yolk, Lost Weekend Farms (Neely's Bend, Madison, TN)
  • TC Craft Tequila (Nashville, TN)
  • CaityPies Graham Cracker Crust

Churro Pie

  • La Lechera Dulce de Leche
  • Ole Smoky Distillery Salty Caramel Whiskey (Gatlinburg, TN)
  • Cinnamon Sugar Rub
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust

Taco Pie

  • Organic Green Pepper & Onion Saute
  • 100% Grass Fed Ground Beef
  • J.M. Thomason Chili Lime Seasoning Blend
  • TC Craft Tequila (Nashville, TN)
  • CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


all pies are available as handpies in market [can reserve in advance]

Full pies or handpie boxes can be special ordered for pick up at our markets or delivery (see Delivery fees on order form)

Father's Day 2018 - June 17th

your dad doesn't want a tie - he wants a pie! 

Browse the PIES page for your dad's favorite pie (Blueberry and Chocolate Pecan are two common Dude Favorites),

or order a fresh pie flavor off of the June Menu (to be announced by 6/1), because you know your dad wants to be hip and fresh like the youth these days.  He's a COOL dad. 

Full pies are $30 (June Menu) - $35 (Off Menu) or get him a box of handpies for $30 - dads love a savory hot pocket of pie.

Pick up at the Hip Donelson Friday night market on 6/15 or get your pie delivered on Saturday 6/16.


Our business

CaityPies are completely handmade, hand wrapped, and hand delivered.  

CaityPies utilize local ingredients and alcohol, and we rotate our flavors every month to bake in season with local produce in Tennessee.

Read our Pies page to learn more about our philosophy for our business, our history, and pies we have created.


your pie

Do you want a pie that will celebrate someone, a special treat, or a pie that sends a message?  Contact us to discuss a design, a flavor, and the timeline to get pie for your next event, as a gift, or just as a treat for yourself!

Use the delivery page to see our current options, delivery area, or start your order.

Look through the FAQ page to see if your question has been asked before and to learn more about our process.

"You could fill that crust with mud and it would still be a good pie.  It's all in the crust." - Lynn


"Cait...your pie was such a hit at the family thanksgiving that dad hid the pie and wasn't sharing it with anyone else!  No one was allowed to take a slice home!" - Erin


"We love caitypies!!" - The thompson kids


"Just had my first bite of pie.  better Put me down for another order. Delicious." - Howard


"If I were a midcentury hobo I would definitely steal that pie off of your window sill" - Alan


"[This is] What heaven must taste like!" - The Walsh Kids