Get your hands on a CaityPie

Come See Us In Market!

The easiest way to find a CaityPie handpie is to show up to our weekly markets right at opening time.

The Bullet Points:

  • Come Early! Occasionally an exciting flavor may sell out within the first 15 minutes of market.

  • In market we always come prepared with the full handpie menu, pot pies, and weekly specials.

  • We ask that you preorder if you’re looking for a specific flavor or more than a half dozen pies!

Ordering CaityPies

Use the link above to order half dozen- full dozen handpie boxes, classic and signature full pies, and party pies!

The Bullet Points:

  • All orders must be placed at least 48 hours before pick up. We prefer as much planning time as possible.

  • Some flavors do not travel well to market, so we request that all cream & signature pies be picked up from our kitchen during baking hours, which are subject to change.

  • We have provided an order page for party orders, but for large party orders please email us at to discuss the size/timing of your event!

Visit Our Wholesale Partners!

Find the CaityPies inventory carried in our wholesale partners’ shops/bars. Call ahead! We can’t guarantee flavors or availability, but you can always call ahead to each shop to see what they have in stock!

Plus, every time you buy a CaityPie in one of our wholesalers shops you are reminding them how great our product is so we can mutually support one anothers’ business - and small business is what makes this world go round!