Our Current Menu


Bourbon Caramel Apple

It's not fall until you're eating a caramel apple on a hay ride. Amiright?


Housemade Bellemeade Bourbon (Nashville, TN) Caramel Sauce

TN Grown, Pesticide Free Apples (Loretto, TN)

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September - November 2018


Brandy Cherry old fashioned

Wisconsin is known for making Old Fashioneds with Brandy and for making our founder Cait, not necessarily in that order.


Sour & Sweet Door County, WI Cherries

Western Grace Brandy & Bitters

Fresh Orange Juice & Zest

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September - November 2018



Sausage & Stout Quiche

- Handpie only -

Super savory, creamy, stout filled breakfast pie is how champions start their day.


Jake's Sage Sausage (Nashville, TN)

Certified Naturally Grown Eggs (Lost Weekend Farms, Madison, TN)

Brie & Cream Cheese

Gotta Get Up To Get Down Wiseacre Coffee Milk Stout (Memphis, TN)

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September-November 2018

Monthly - September menu



Spiked Smores

Dreaming of cooler fall evenings and weekend bonfires and flannel and coffee and bourbon...


Housemade Dark Chocolate Pastry Cream w/Buffalo Trace Bourbon Creme

Graham Cracker & Coffee Crumble

Housemade Toasted Marshmallow Cream

Ghirardelli Chocolate Drizzle


Available September 2018



Buffalo Beer Can Chicken

- handpie only -

If you watch a football game without buffalo chicken dip.... did the football even happen at all?  Asking for a friend.


Beard & Bark Smoked Beer Can Chicken (Nashville, TN)

Frank's Red Hot Sauce

Cream Cheese & Cheddar Mix

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September 2018


Whiskey Sweet Potato

If we close our eyes and sit in the air conditioning we can pretend it’s fall even when its still 90 degrees in Nashville.


Organic Sweet Potatoes

Certified Naturally Grown Eggs (Nashville, TN)

Redneck Riviera Whiskey (Nashville, TN)

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September 2018

Check out our History Page to see a list of the

Past Flavor Hall of Fame