Our Current Menu


Bourbon Caramel Apple

It's not fall until you're eating a caramel apple on a hay ride. Amiright?


Housemade Bellemeade Bourbon (Nashville, TN) Caramel Sauce

TN Grown, Pesticide Free Apples (Loretto, TN)

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September - November 2018


Black Forest Cherry

Our Wisconsin Old Fashioned Cherry is temporarily being replaced with this Twin Peaks inspired flavor


Dark, Sweet Cherries


70% Dark Chocolate Chunks

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September - November 2018



Sausage & Stout Quiche

- Handpie only -

Super savory, creamy, stout filled breakfast pie is how champions start their day.


Breakfast Sage Sausage (Nashville, TN)

Farm Fresh Chicken & Duck Eggs (Stomping Ground Herbal, Inglewood, TN)


Founder’s Breakfast Stout

CaityPies Cornmeal Crust


Available September-November 2018

Monthly - October menu

[this month we will also offer daily & weekly specials to celebrate our birthday! check our instagram and market table for these specials]



Dirty chai pear crumble

Not that kind of dirty…like espresso and chai kinda dirty. Better than pumpkin spice kind of fall flavors.


Fresh Pears

Chai Spices

Housemade Oat & Pecan Crumble

Red Eye Rye Coffee Flavored Rye Whiskey


Available October 2018



Peanut Butter Mud Cup

If you don’t love peanut butter cups… move along. This is for the true fans.


Housemade Milk Chocolate Pastry Cream

Housemade Peanut Butter Pastry Cream w/TN Mud Creme Liquor

Milk Chocolate Coating

Reeses Crumble


Available October 2018


TN BBQ Mac N Cheese

Cold weather calls for creamy savory pie fillings and they just get better when we add smoked meats.


Housemade Cheddar Cheese Sauce


Smoked Pulled Pork by Beard & Bark (Nashville, TN)

Housemade TN Whiskey BBQ Sauce


Available October 2018

Check out our History Page to see a list of the

Past Flavor Hall of Fame