Past Flavor Hall of Fame


These flavors have been offered on past menus. Pies that can only be made with rare/seasonal ingredients are indicated with *.

Not all pies can be recreated for current ordering. Please send us a message to discuss a flavor from the past or a new creation for your pie needs.

Our Current Menu reflects the best seasonal ingredients/flavors that we can offer each month.

Please consider the current menu before pulling up a pie from the past.

Savory Pies

Bourbon Cheddar Burger

Buffalo Beer Can Chicken

Pale Ale Pot Pie

Spicy Tomato Bloody Mary

Steak N Stout

Taco Pie

TN BBQ (Mac&Cheese) Pie

Wisconsin Bacon Egg and Beer Cheese


(Can be ordered anytime of year)



French Silk



Coconut Cream

Coffee Cream

Lemon Meringue

Sweet/Cocktail Pies

Black & Blueberry Rock & Rye

Black Bottomed Spiced Rum Pecan

Black Forest Cherry

Bourbon Bacon Caramel Apple *

Bourbon Glazed Peach *

Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry*


Caramel Sweet Corn Custard *

Churro Pie

Eleven My Eggo Stranger Things

Grapefruit Stiegl Radler Pie

Irish Coffee

Key Lime Margarita

Lemon Drop Lavender Chess*

Mexican Hot Chocolate

Pancake Overload Pie

Peanut Butter Mud

Pina Colada

Shaker Hard Lemonade

Spiked S’mores

Strawberry Rhubarb Rum*

Whiskey Sweet Potato