Thanksgiving Pie Preorders


Thanksgiving Pie Preorders

from 22.00

Please select a pick up time on Wednesday 11/27 or the morning of Thursday 11/28 from Hunters Station in Five Points, East Nashville.

There will be no opportunity for early or late pick up this year; however, we will keep the freezers of Hunters Station, Demeters Commons, and Porter Road Butcher heavily stocked with frozen Classic Apple and Classic Chicken Pot Pies or those who need to travel and would prefer a Take & Bake pie.

Read more about the various flavors and options below.

Add To Cart


  • Classic Pumpkin - signature CaityPies butter & lard crust, traditional custard filling with fresh pumpkin puree and CaityPies/Beard & Bark Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix

  • Mocha Chess - signature CaityPies butter & lard crust, traditional chess pie filling with smooth dark chocolate and hints of espresso

  • Cran-Raspberry Gingersnap - gingersnap cookie crumb crust, tart & smooth filling made with fresh cranberry and raspberry puree, sugared cranberry topping

  • Whiskey Sweet Potato - signature CaityPies butter & lard crust, creamy sweet potato puree custard with a hint of whiskey, topped with vanilla whipped cream

  • Spiced Rum Chocolate Pecan - signature CaityPies butter & lard crust, sweet browned butter filling with toasted pecans, dark chocolate chunks, and a splash of spiced rum

  • Bourbon Caramel Apple Crumble - signature CaityPies butter & lard crust, fresh local tart apples with a house-made bourbon caramel sauce, topped with our signature oat crumble

FRANKENPIE: One slice of each fresh baked pie, listed above, in one pie tin.


  • Pie Poppers: one dozen of either our Bourbon Glazed Apple or PSL (Pumpkin Spice Latte) Pasty (great for entertaining a crowd)

  • Sweet Mix: a half dozen of the sweet handpies (gf and v box also available) on our normal menu (makes a great gift)

All Orders placed & paid for via the website are final.

If you do not allow 48 hours for us to make your pie we cannot fill your order.

If you do not show up at your designated pick up time to retrieve your pie we WILL NOT hold it, as pies are perishable. All unclaimed pies are donated to local businesses & families in need.

ALLERGEN NOTICE: Gluten Free products are not guaranteed as gluten free for those with extreme allergies. We work in a shared kitchen space with wheat flour, nuts, milk, eggs, & shellfish - while we can guarantee that your pie does not include allergen ingredients, we cannot guarantee that they have not been in indirect contact with allergens.