our flavors change each month

follow our instagram @caitypiesnashville to see what's on our current menu


browse our past flavors and ask whether its available for special order

Our Pies

CaityPies are always:



+In Season Produce

+Alcohol Infused Flavors

+Featuring Local/Small Business Products

+Preservative Free

CaityPies are made with a turn of the century lard/butter crust with the addition of salty cornmeal for a hefty & flaky crust that make a firm home for each of our handpie fillings.  

CaityPies specializes in handpies which, much like traditional Southern fry pies, are handmade half-moon shaped 6" treats, equal to one serving of pie.  CaityPies are baked instead of fried.

CaityPies also produces traditional round pies in both Full (9") and Mini (5") sizes in many of our sweet and savory flavors.  Not all flavors can be transferred to the traditional round pie method due to restrictions in the ingredient/baking methods.

We are happy to design your pie with any words/shapes you'd like!  Our pies have been used to celebrate anniversaries, birthdays, baby showers, and a number of other celebrations.  Let us know what you're looking for and we will help make it a reality!

See our FAQ Page to learn more about Dietary Restrictions and Re-heating Instructions!  Use the Contact Page if you have remaining questions.


Our past flavors: 

Some of these flavors will pop back into the menu seasonally or may still be available by special request.  Talk to Cait for details!


Bourbon Bacon Caramel Apple *

Bourbon Chocolate Cherry

Bourbon Peach *

Black Bottomed Spiced Rum Pecan

Caramel Corn Custard *

Cranberry Custard *

Mexican Hot Chocolate

S’mores Handpie

Spiced Rum Pecan

Strawberry Cheesecake Pie *

Sweet Cherry Wine

Tennessee Silk Peppermint

Tequila Shaker Lemon

Whiskey Pumpkin Corn *

Whiskey Sweet Potato


Mushroom Ale Gravy Pie

Pale Ale Pot Pie

Wisconsin Bacon Egg and Beer Cheese

* Indicates that the flavor requires In Season Produce which may or may not be available if it's not on the current menu!


Non-Alcoholic/Dietary Restriction Base Flavors:

Cherry Pie: Can be made traditional, vegan, gluten free (cookie crust).

Apple Pie: Can be made traditional, vegan, gluten free (cookie crust).

Chocolate Pie: Can be made traditional or gluten free (cookie crust).



Follow us on Instagram and Facebook to see what we are currently baking in our kitchen @caitypiesnashville